{
  "status": "passed_fixed_reference_retention_check",
  "model_qualified": false,
  "result": {
    "schema": "biosim.joint_author_comparison_v3",
    "status": "completed_external_comparison",
    "model_qualified": false,
    "paired_finite_records": 899,
    "paired_metrics": {
      "cached_released": {
        "finite_records": 899,
        "attempted_records": 899,
        "statuses": {
          "finite": 899
        },
        "qm_force_rmse_ev_a": 0.06851868659618658,
        "qm_configuration_mean_rmse_ev_a": 0.06634727063569429,
        "mm_force_rmse_ev_a": 0.00751129667245026,
        "mm_configuration_mean_rmse_ev_a": 0.007290960712631348,
        "within_molecule_relative_energy_records": 895,
        "within_molecule_relative_energy_rmse_ev": 0.17371435246207625
      },
      "joint_v3": {
        "finite_records": 899,
        "attempted_records": 899,
        "statuses": {
          "finite": 899
        },
        "qm_force_rmse_ev_a": 0.0677277105519822,
        "qm_configuration_mean_rmse_ev_a": 0.06563120370616096,
        "mm_force_rmse_ev_a": 0.007409047092699889,
        "mm_configuration_mean_rmse_ev_a": 0.007194320063061881,
        "within_molecule_relative_energy_records": 895,
        "within_molecule_relative_energy_rmse_ev": 0.16804613795479842
      }
    },
    "relative_error_changes_percent": {
      "qm_force_rmse_ev_a": -1.1543946381605052,
      "mm_force_rmse_ev_a": -1.3612773427709168,
      "within_molecule_relative_energy_rmse_ev": -3.262951176423534
    },
    "all_three_aggregate_errors_no_worse": true,
    "per_source": {
      "cached_released": {
        "mini-proteins-0": {
          "finite_records": 185,
          "attempted_records": 185,
          "statuses": {
            "finite": 185
          },
          "qm_force_rmse_ev_a": 0.07322404958082845,
          "qm_configuration_mean_rmse_ev_a": 0.07224131994539214,
          "mm_force_rmse_ev_a": 0.009078613405452804,
          "mm_configuration_mean_rmse_ev_a": 0.00900381753950117,
          "within_molecule_relative_energy_records": 185,
          "within_molecule_relative_energy_rmse_ev": 0.3530837122180168
        },
        "peptides": {
          "finite_records": 714,
          "attempted_records": 714,
          "statuses": {
            "finite": 714
          },
          "qm_force_rmse_ev_a": 0.06522277804094428,
          "qm_configuration_mean_rmse_ev_a": 0.06473261954339164,
          "mm_force_rmse_ev_a": 0.0068276743474112115,
          "mm_configuration_mean_rmse_ev_a": 0.006776899311128992,
          "within_molecule_relative_energy_records": 710,
          "within_molecule_relative_energy_rmse_ev": 0.07453636314288964
        }
      },
      "joint_v3": {
        "mini-proteins-0": {
          "finite_records": 185,
          "attempted_records": 185,
          "statuses": {
            "finite": 185
          },
          "qm_force_rmse_ev_a": 0.07222935618036457,
          "qm_configuration_mean_rmse_ev_a": 0.07123770072638366,
          "mm_force_rmse_ev_a": 0.008943803467051516,
          "mm_configuration_mean_rmse_ev_a": 0.008878752540658157,
          "within_molecule_relative_energy_records": 185,
          "within_molecule_relative_energy_rmse_ev": 0.34464980161819064
        },
        "peptides": {
          "finite_records": 714,
          "attempted_records": 714,
          "statuses": {
            "finite": 714
          },
          "qm_force_rmse_ev_a": 0.06458049386483862,
          "qm_configuration_mean_rmse_ev_a": 0.06409859903273628,
          "mm_force_rmse_ev_a": 0.0067403516716625965,
          "mm_configuration_mean_rmse_ev_a": 0.006689040869490545,
          "within_molecule_relative_energy_records": 710,
          "within_molecule_relative_energy_rmse_ev": 0.06816933809730423
        }
      }
    },
    "candidate_elapsed_seconds": 40.578071617055684,
    "candidate_peak_gpu_allocated_bytes": 1154629120,
    "candidate_runtime": {
      "python": "3.11.10",
      "torch": "2.4.1+cu124",
      "numpy": "1.26.4",
      "device": "cuda",
      "gpu": "NVIDIA RTX 2000 Ada Generation"
    },
    "raw_candidate_review_sha256": "e92c4c7907cf015bb8fd1b1d419b9001c18835743ad1ace64da3601168fee467",
    "baseline_inference_repeated": false,
    "plan_sha256": "3a6e73b66108b4cc001e79a0c5858bcaabdcb2fc40fd788c95667867920729c3",
    "candidate_records_sha256": "42c2719a55a7cea5d6e50b67161305369089982f2bb5ad8cc0e0afc0f13a7fa4",
    "baseline_records_sha256": "d7b0d9ad604f25a7d15a8cd38a7458668697ea5bdff63eca0b9e1f1ec3cc547f",
    "scope": "Same 899 author-reserved peptide/miniprotein configurations and native BMS reference mode; no fitting. Earlier baseline and assessment exposure retained. This is a reference-retention check, not production dynamics or reaction-rate qualification."
  },
  "audit": {
    "status": "passed_external_identity_and_summary_audit",
    "records": 899,
    "energy_difference_records": 895,
    "all_finite": true,
    "metrics": {
      "cached_released": {
        "qm_force_rmse_ev_a": 0.06851868659618658,
        "mm_force_rmse_ev_a": 0.00751129667245026,
        "within_molecule_relative_energy_rmse_ev": 0.17371435246207625
      },
      "joint_v3": {
        "qm_force_rmse_ev_a": 0.0677277105519822,
        "mm_force_rmse_ev_a": 0.007409047092699889,
        "within_molecule_relative_energy_rmse_ev": 0.16804613795479842
      }
    },
    "source_counts": {
      "peptides": 714,
      "mini-proteins-0": 185
    },
    "baseline_inference_repeated": false,
    "result_archive_sha256": "19f2c55977bad5549aa2cd951063a01feb65a77e84ead857befd8b2f4a4c0c0e",
    "operator_sha256": "6961f4930314c6fe9ec74814fabaa4b51829619c4c9e5406b3382dca0ff8fa9f",
    "scope": "Independent record-identity and metric-summary recomputation from the already checked inference routine; no repeated model/QM calls or fitting. All 899 retained; four singleton configurations excluded only from the energy-difference statistic."
  },
  "provider_stop_confirmed": true,
  "provider_state_independently_checked": "EXITED"
}